Ravvy
Login

Head to head · Watches

Men's Classic Sutton 4-Hand Automatic Watch vs Men's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap

Ravvy scores Men's Classic Sutton 4-Hand Automatic Watch at 87.43 and Men's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap at 89.38. Men's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap takes the overall pick, best for professionals seeking a slim formal watch for office and evening wear.

Bulova Men's Classic Sutton 4-Hand Automatic Watch, 24-Hour Sub Dial, Open Aperture, Self-Winding, Exhibition Caseback, Double Curved Mineral Crystal, Luminous Hands, 42mm Brown Strap/Brown Dial
87.4

$401

A stunning entry-level luxury timepiece for those who value mechanical aesthetics over ruggedness, accepting the modest water resistance for superior visual design.

Ravvy pick

Bulova Men's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap Watch, Roman Numeral Markers, 41mm Stainless
89.4

$180

Buy this watch if you want a reliable, ultra-thin formal timepiece that looks significantly more expensive than its price point, provided you don't mind the lack of date or lume.

How they score

FactorMen's Classic Sutton 4-Hand Automatic WatchMen's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap
Precision81.5–
Aesthetics94.2–
Versatility84.575
Craftsmanship88–
Water Resistance40–
Value–94
Elegance–92.5
Legibility–85
Portability–98

Men's Classic Sutton 4-Hand Automatic Watch

What owners praise

  • Intricate open-heart skeleton dial design
  • Reliable self-winding automatic movement
  • Elegant croc-embossed leather strap with deployment buckle
  • Exhibition caseback reveals the inner gears
  • Sophisticated 24-hour sub-dial complication

What to know first

  • Limited 30m water resistance is not suitable for swimming
  • Mineral crystal is more prone to scratches than sapphire
  • Requires regular wear or a winder to maintain time

Skip it if outdoor athletes or swimmers needing high water resistance and durability

Men's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap

What owners praise

  • Ultra-slim 6mm case profile
  • Timeless Roman numeral aesthetic
  • Lightweight and comfortable for all-day wear
  • Reliable Japanese quartz movement
  • Excellent value for a name-brand dress watch

What to know first

  • Minimal 30m water resistance
  • Mineral crystal is prone to scratches
  • No date window or luminous markers

Skip it if active individuals needing high water resistance or nighttime visibility

Specs side by side

SpecMen's Classic Sutton 4-Hand Automatic WatchMen's Classic 3-Hand Quartz Black Leather Strap
UPC961613274236 042429466982042429493155 696720151643
ASINB004I5GOK8B0088BMX44
Bands11
ShapeRoundRound
CrystalCrystalmineral
DisplayAnalogAnalog
PatternSolidRoman Numerals
MaterialStainless-steelStainless-steel
Batteries1 Lithium Ion batteries required. (included)1 Lithium Metal batteries required. (included)
CharacterFashionFashion
Band ColorBrownBlack
Band Width22 millimeters20 millimeters

Other options in this category

Casio A158WA Series | Unisex Digital Watch | Vintage | WR | 100 SEC Stop Watch | Daily Alarm | Regular Time Keeping: Hour, Minute, Second, PM, Date, Day | Led Light | 7 Yr Battery Silver A158WA-1DF
93.7

Best for retro enthusiasts and practical minimalists

  • 7-Year Battery Life
  • Stainless Steel Link Bracelet
  • Daily Alarm and Stopwatch
$30
Casio MDV106 Series | Unisex Analog Watch | 200M WR | Stainless Steel Case | Resin Band | 2 Hand Analog (HR, Min, SEC) | Date Display | Screw Down Crown/Screw Down Caseback | 3 Year Battery Black Resi
93.7

Best for budget-conscious enthusiasts and weekend divers

  • Stainless Steel Construction
  • 200M Water Resistance
  • Screw-Down Crown & Caseback
$66