97.7
Best for families and travelers who want a fast-paced game without turn-based waiting
- 144 high-quality letter tiles
- Signature yellow banana zip pouch
- Zero-setup simultaneous gameplay
$12
Head to head · Games & Puzzles
Ultimate Puzzle Challenge! vs Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles
Ravvy scores Ultimate Puzzle Challenge! at 10.46 and Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles at 89.57. Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles takes the overall pick, best for true crime fans and puzzle lovers seeking a portable mental challenge.
$6
The best value for parents seeking a comprehensive activity book that swaps screen time for genuine cognitive development despite the heavy physical weight of the volume.
Ravvy pick
$11
True crime enthusiasts should buy this book for its engaging thematic variety and practical lie-flat design, even if some puzzles feel more like general logic than actual detective work.
How they score
| Factor | Ultimate Puzzle Challenge! | Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles |
|---|---|---|
| Variety | 98 | 92 |
| Portability | 72 | 90 |
| Engagement Level | 94 | – |
| Educational Value | 95 | – |
| Age Appropriateness | 90 | – |
| Physical Design | – | 96 |
| Value for Money | – | 89 |
| Mental Challenge | – | 84.5 |
Ultimate Puzzle Challenge!
What owners praise
- Over 250 pages of high-quality content
- Diverse mix of logic, math, and word games
- Excellent paper quality that handles erasing well
- Fosters independent play and critical thinking
- Trusted educational brand with proven design
What to know first
- Book is quite heavy and bulky for small backpacks
- Binding can make it difficult to lay flat
- Some logic puzzles may require adult explanation
Skip it if toddlers or children who lack the fine motor skills for small-scale writing
Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles
What owners praise
- Convenient spiral binding lies flat
- Diverse mix of puzzle types prevents boredom
- High quality paper resists ink bleed
- Thematic crime elements add immersion
- Includes a full answer key for self-correction
What to know first
- Text size may be small for some seniors
- Some logic puzzles are repetitive
- Difficulty levels are not clearly marked
Skip it if young children or those who prefer traditional, single-format puzzle books
Specs side by side
| Spec | Ultimate Puzzle Challenge! | Brain Games Criminal Mind Puzzles |
|---|---|---|
| Edition | Illustrated | – |
| ISBN-10 | 1684372615 | 1640306730 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-1684372614 | 978-1640306738 |
| Language | English | English |
| Publisher | Highlights Press | Publications International, Ltd. |
| Dimensions | 8.44 x 0.55 x 10.88 inches | 7.81 x 0.75 x 9.13 inches |
| Grade level | 3 - 7 | – |
| Item Weight | 2.31 pounds | 13.6 ounces |
| Reading age | 6+ years, from customers | – |
| Print length | 256 pages | 192 pages |
| Part of series | Part of series : Highlights Jumbo Books & Pads | Part of series : Brain Games |
| Publication date | February 5, 2019 | December 15, 2018 |
Other options in this category
95.4
Best for competitive speedcubers and enthusiasts seeking maximum customization
- Core-to-Corner Magnetic System
- 7 Magnet Strength Levels
- GES Pro Elasticity System
$40
95.2
Best for solo travelers and parents looking for screen-free logic building
- 120 progressive challenges
- Multiple 2D and 3D play modes
- Sturdy travel-ready construction
$13