95.4
Best for content creators and professional photographers on the move
- USB 3.2 Gen 2 Interface
- 6-foot drop protection
- AES 256-bit hardware encryption
$214
Head to head · Storage & Drives
WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive vs Expansion Desktop, 4TB, External Hard Drive
Ravvy scores WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive at 89.65 and Expansion Desktop, 4TB, External Hard Drive at 85.35. WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive takes the overall pick, best for creative professionals and home users with massive media libraries.
Ravvy pick
Western Digital
WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive
89.7
$725
A reliable high-capacity archive solution for users who prioritize massive storage volume and hardware security over portability and silent operation.
85.3
$183
A solid choice for high-capacity desktop archiving that trades portability and SSD speed for affordability and included data recovery services.
How they score
| Factor | WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive | Expansion Desktop, 4TB, External Hard Drive |
|---|---|---|
| Quietness | 70 | 85 |
| Data Security | 92 | – |
| Transfer Speed | 65 | – |
| Value for Money | 89 | 89 |
| Storage Capacity | 98 | – |
| Portability | – | 30 |
| Storage Density | – | 92 |
| Setup Simplicity | – | 96.5 |
WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive
What owners praise
- Enormous 16TB capacity for extensive archiving
- Hardware-based 256-bit AES encryption for security
- Robust 3-year manufacturer warranty
- Plug-and-play compatibility with Windows and Mac
- Included backup software suite for automation
What to know first
- Requires a separate AC power adapter
- Mechanical drive noise is audible in quiet rooms
- Slower transfer speeds compared to modern SSDs
Skip it if users needing portable storage or high-speed video editing drives
Expansion Desktop, 4TB, External Hard Drive
What owners praise
- Generous 4TB capacity for the price
- Included 1-year data recovery service plan
- Sturdy enclosure with premium materials
- Instant recognition on Windows and Mac
- Fast USB 3.0 interface for sequential transfers
What to know first
- Requires an external power adapter
- Mechanical 5400 RPM speed limits random access
- Bulky form factor not meant for travel
Skip it if digital nomads or those needing high-speed video editing drives
Specs side by side
| Spec | WD 16TB My Book Desktop External Hard Drive | Expansion Desktop, 4TB, External Hard Drive |
|---|---|---|
| UPC | 718037879109 | – |
| ASIN | B08KTSWHZB | B093BVXYSV |
| GTIN | 718037879109 | – |
| Brand | Western Digital | Seagate |
| Color | Black | Black |
| Model Name | My Book | Seagate Expansion |
| Unit Count | 1 Count | – |
| Form Factor | Desktop | 3.5-inch |
| Item Weight | 2 pounds | 950 g |
| Media Speed | 150 MB/s | 120 |
| Manufacturer | Western Digital Technologies, Inc. | Seagate |
| Model Number | WDBBGB0160HBK-NESN | STKP4000400 |
Other options in this category
89.6
Best for security camera owners and budget conscious drone pilots
- 4K Ultra HD ready
- 95MB/s maximum read speed
- UHS-I Class 10 V30 standard
$65
89.2
Best for teachers, small business owners, and photographers providing digital proofs
- 320GB total storage across 10 units
- 360 degree rotating metal shield
- Plug and play functionality
$54