Ravvy
Login

Head to head · Garage & Storage

Metal Garage Storage Cabinet vs Craftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage

Ravvy scores Metal Garage Storage Cabinet at 90.37 and Craftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage at 90.63. Craftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage takes the overall pick, best for homeowners needing rust-proof storage for heavy bins and workshop equipment.

Yizosh Metal Garage Storage Cabinet with 2 Doors and 5 Adjustable Shelves - 71" Steel Lockable File Cabinet,Locking Tool Cabinets for Office,Home,Garage,Gym,School (Black) Black 71"H x 31.5"W x 15.7"D

$130

Buy this cabinet if you need maximum weight capacity and security for under 150 dollars, provided you are comfortable with a 45-minute assembly process.

Ravvy pick

CX Craftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage Shelves, Garage Organization

$99

Buy this unit if you need maximum weight capacity in a damp environment, accepting that its utility aesthetic is strictly functional.

How they score

FactorMetal Garage Storage CabinetCraftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage
Security88–
Assembly Ease72.5–
Weight Capacity9591
Material Quality84–
Space Efficiency9188
Stability–86.5
Assembly Speed–96
Moisture Resistance–98

Metal Garage Storage Cabinet

What owners praise

  • High 180-pound weight capacity per shelf
  • Adjustable interior layout for custom storage needs
  • Full 180-degree door swing for easy access
  • Durable powder-coated finish resists rust and scratches
  • Includes a secure three-point locking system with two keys

What to know first

  • Requires significant assembly time and patience
  • Metal panels can be prone to denting during shipping
  • Locking mechanism can feel stiff initially

Skip it if users looking for a pre-assembled furniture piece or decorative luxury aesthetics

Craftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage

What owners praise

  • Resists rust and corrosion in humid basements
  • Extra deep 24 inch shelves fit large storage totes
  • Adjustable feet solve stability issues on sloped garage floors
  • Simple tool free assembly takes under 15 minutes
  • Heavier material density compared to standard plastic racks

What to know first

  • Industrial aesthetic is not suited for living areas
  • Plastic can bow if 200lb limit is concentrated in one spot
  • Total height may require wall anchoring for safety

Skip it if displaying fine decor or use in high traffic living rooms

Specs side by side

SpecMetal Garage Storage CabinetCraftsman 5-Tier Heavy Duty Plastic Storage
ASINB0B3MB5F56B095Z4WGLL
Size71"H x 31.5"W x 15.7"D (5 Shelves)24"x40"x72"
BrandYizosh–
ColorBlackBlack, Red
ShapeRectangularRectangular
MaterialMetalPolypropylene
Base TypeLegs–
Lock TypeKey–
Room TypeGarageGarage, Basement, Utility Room, Equipment Room, Janitor’s Closet, Tool Shed, Workshop, Gardening Shed, Laundry Room, Pantry, Or Anywhere Else
Brand NameYizoshCX
Door StyleDouble door, Double door–
Item Depth15.7 inches24 inches

Other options in this category

MonsterRax 4x8 Overhead Garage Storage Rack, Gray, 24"-45" Height Hammertone 24"-45"
94.2

Best for homeowners looking to maximize garage floor space and store seasonal gear

  • 120 cubic feet of storage potential
  • Veteren-owned American brand quality
  • Adjustable 24 to 45 inch drop depth
$140