93.6
Best for adults with high tolerance or significant occasional insomnia
- 100% Drug-Free
- Non-Habit Forming
- Pectin-Based Texture
$11
Head to head · Sleep
Extra Strength Sleep vs Sleep Support Gummy Supplement, * 3 mg Melatonin
Ravvy scores Extra Strength Sleep at 89.44 and Sleep Support Gummy Supplement, * 3 mg Melatonin at 89.74. Sleep Support Gummy Supplement, * 3 mg Melatonin takes the overall pick, best for light sleepers and those needing a gentle wind down routine.
89.4
$13
Buy these if you need a reliable, high-potency sleep aid with a pleasant taste, provided you are comfortable with a 5mg melatonin dosage.
Ravvy pick
$20
Buy OLLY Sleep if you want a tasty, low-dose melatonin supplement that helps you drift off naturally, though you may find the 45-day supply runs out quickly.
How they score
| Factor | Extra Strength Sleep | Sleep Support Gummy Supplement, * 3 mg Melatonin |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor Quality | 94.2 | – |
| Sleep Efficacy | 86 | – |
| Ease of Digestion | 89.5 | – |
| Value per Serving | 82.5 | – |
| Ingredient Transparency | 91 | – |
| Taste | – | 94.5 |
| Effectiveness | – | 87 |
| Value for Money | – | 82 |
| Ingredient Purity | – | 91 |
| Wakefulness Next Day | – | 93 |
Extra Strength Sleep
What owners praise
- NSF Certified for ingredient purity
- Includes L-Theanine to promote mental relaxation
- Pleasant blackberry and mint flavor profile
- Drug-free and non-habit forming
- Gluten-free with no synthetic colors
What to know first
- Higher sugar content than tablet alternatives
- Melatonin can cause grogginess if not given 7 to 8 hours of sleep
- Gummies may stick together in warm environments
Skip it if individuals sensitive to melatonin or those seeking a very low-dose sedative
Sleep Support Gummy Supplement, * 3 mg Melatonin
What owners praise
- Delicious blackberry and mint flavor profile
- Moderate melatonin dosage prevents morning grogginess
- NSF certified for quality and ingredient accuracy
- Includes L-Theanine for mental relaxation
- Gluten free with no synthetic colors or flavors
What to know first
- Only a 45-day supply per bottle
- Gummies can be sensitive to heat during shipping
- Sugary coating may not suit everyone's dental preferences
Skip it if individuals with severe chronic insomnia requiring high-dose prescriptions
Specs side by side
| Spec | Extra Strength Sleep | Sleep Support Gummy Supplement, * 3 mg Melatonin |
|---|---|---|
| UPC | 852933008413 | 840160201738 |
| ASIN | B07RN1Z2RL | B0CRMWK9PH |
| Color | Purple | – |
| Flavor | Blackberry | Blackberry |
| Diet Type | Gluten Free | Gluten Free |
| Item Form | Gummy | Gummy |
| Brand Name | OLLY | OLLY |
| Item Shape | Round | – |
| Model Name | a Strength Sleep Gummy, Occasional Sleep Support, 5 mg Melatonin, L-Theanine, Chamomile, Lemon Balm, Sleep Aid, BlackBerry - 50 Count | – |
| Unit Count | 50 Count | 90 Count |
| Dosage Form | Gummy | Gummy |
| Item Weight | 6.2 ounces | 9.76 ounces |
Other options in this category
93.6
Best for adults with high tolerance or persistent occasional sleeplessness
- Drug free and non habit forming
- Fast acting pectin formula
- Natural strawberry flavor
$16
93.5
Best for adults with occasional insomnia who need a stronger alternative to diphenhydramine
- 25mg Doxylamine Succinate per tab
- Fall asleep 33 percent faster
- Single tablet dosage
$14